Do you need an easy dessert that will blow people’s minds?! Then you need to bake pie inside a cake! It’s easier than you think.
The flavorful vanilla cakes hide tangy cherry pies that are revealed as you cut into it.
If you love quick and easy desserts with cake mix as I do, you have to give this pie cake recipe a try!
Jump to:
This post was originally shared on January 18, 2016. I have updated it to include more detailed instructions.
I made this pie cake for my son’s birthday party last week and had to share it. It was between this cake or Brown Sugar Pie and the pie cake recipe won out!
I thought about making another one so I could take pretty, styled photos of the steps and make a gorgeous, Pinterest-worthy post.
But I can’t! I’m too excited to share it. So let’s consider this pie cake to be in the wild, in a raw landscape, its natural habitat.
Pie Cake Inspiration
YOU GUYS! PIE INSIDE A CAKE!
I want to be very clear. This pie in a cake was not an original idea that I came up with. I had a standing date with Home and Family every day from 10 am – 2 pm.
Around Halloween, they had the most amazing, creative human ever assembled on to talk about his fantastic Blood and Guts cake.
If you don’t know Charles Phoenix, you need to go spend hours on his site. He’s crazy inspiring to me.
Long story short, I had to throw my son a *Five Nights at Freddy’s party for his birthday and it was my chance to try my hand at making a pie cake.
Why This Recipe Works
This is a very doable dessert. I don’t feel like I have baking skills. But trust me, this is super easy. (Not quite as easy as dump cakes, but still).
There are much harder versions of this pie cake on the internet. You can find recipes that are perfect for Thanksgiving/Friendsgiving and include all the best seasonal flavors.
Some of them include a variety of cake flavors and a variety of pie flavors. With 4 layers. It’s a lot.
This recipe is the easier way to go that is just as delicious! And while I used simple white cakes with cherry pie, you can mix and match other flavors.
This tutorial for how to bake a cake inside a pie will work no matter what flavors you choose.
This is such a fun dessert to serve at a kid’s party! My Pinata Cake is a fun surprise cake idea but so is this! And of course, it would be awesome for a Halloween party.
This Chocolate Truffle Cake is also super easy and looks harder than it is.
Ingredient
- White Cake Mix (for each layer you want to make)
- Pie (for each layer you want to make)
- Frosting
- Extra Cherry Pie Filling
You can make this as many layers of pie cake as you want. I did 2. So you would need a boxed cake mix (I used white cake) and ready-made or frozen pies (I used cherry pies) for each layer.
You’ll also need the ingredients to make the cake per the directions on the box.
I used store-bought vanilla frosting, but you can use your favorite flavor or make your own frosting.
This vanilla buttercream is my favorite. But Russian Buttercream and Cool Whip Frosting are great too!
Don’t skip the extra cherry pie filling. It makes a delicious topping. Or you can decorate it any way you want to.
How to Bake Pie Inside a Cake
Bake the pies the night before you plan to bake them into the cake layers. Or make them earlier in the day. They just need to be cooled.
Or use store-bought, already baked pies, that are the size of normal pies.
Follow the directions on the back of the boxed cake mix and make in a stand mixer.
Mix it a lot. Over beating makes the batter stronger.
Prepare your springform pan by spraying it with baking spray or using butter and flour.
Pour in half the batter.
Plop your first cherry pie in the center.
Cover with the rest of the batter.
Bake.
And repeat for the second layer.
Let the pie cake cool to room temperature before decorating.
I suck at frosting cakes so I had my neighbor decorate it for me. But I’m sharing my decorating hacks below in case you don’t have a skilled neighbor.
To Serve
Top with a can of cherry pie filling. This is optional but if you’re doing anything spooky it’s a must.
My in-laws always serve cake with ice cream. So you can do what you prefer. Because there is so much going on with this cake, it’s perfectly fine to serve on its own.
THE. CROWD. GOES. WILD. People thought I was a marvel for having come up with such the incredible idea of baking pie inside cake.
And sometimes, when there are older people involved, it is easier to just take the credit and not try to explain proper sourcing and internets and etiquette, blah blah blah.
Everyone’s reactions were so awesome. I really feel like all cakes should have pie in them. It’s one of my New Year’s resolutions.
It’s a bit hard to get small slices of cake when there are two pies inside.
So do your best. The pie cake is on the sweet side. So keep that in mind when choosing what kind of frosting to use.
Pie Cake is the most perfect dessert for Halloween. Especially this version with the goopy cherry pie filling. It really does look like guts. Ew.
You’ve got to try this delicious pie inside a cake! It’s super easy, tastes delicious and is always a crowd-pleaser!
Tips and Tricks
- I wouldn’t go above 3 layers of pie cake. It seems like it wouldn’t be very stable.
- I used frozen pies so I made them the night before and let them sit overnight so they were at room temperature.
- I’m not going to lie, it was a little tricky to cut through and I should have gotten out the electric carver like Charles suggests. But this cake saw is our favorite cutter and it seemed really fitting for this cake especially.
Frequently Asked Questions
Oddly, a pie baked in a cake doesn’t get too dry. The crust is protected by the cake mix so it doesn’t dry out.
If you’re using a store-bought or frozen pie, it’s more simple than you might think. They should just slide out in one piece. If you’re hesitant, you can try long, offset spatulas or grab an extra pair of hands.
If you’re planning to eat the pie cake within a day or so, it should be fine, but it’s better when baked and eaten within a day or two.
Related Recipes
- Make this yummy Fireball Pumpkin Pie.
- A quick and easy Frozen Peanut Butter Pie recipe.
- My Frozen Strawberry Pie is also super easy and sets up in the freezer making it refreshing and delicious.
- This basic Chocolate Pie from Crystal and Comp sounds SO yummy!
- I definitely want to give this Blackberry Custard Pie from Celebrations at Home a try!
How to Bake Pie Inside a Cake
Equipment
- Springform pan
- Measuring spoons
- measuring cup
Ingredients
- 30.5 ounces White cake mix Plus the ingredients the boxed cake mix calls for.
- 80 ounces Store-bought cherry pie
- 16 ounce Canned frosting or homemade
- 21 ounce Cherry Pie Filling optional
Instructions
- If you purchase a frozen pie, bake them off the night before you want to bake the cake. They should be cool enough that you can touch them.
- If you used store-bought pie you don’t have to cook it first.
- Use a stand mixer to make your boxed cake mix.
- I make each box individually to ensure that the layers are even (I’m a terrible estimator).
- Over mix the cake batter by a few minutes which help to make the batter stronger to support the pie in the layer.
- Once batter is ready, prepare your springform pan (spray with cooking spray and a light dusting of flour) and add half of the cake batter from one boxed mix.
- Add one of the pies then top with the other half of the cake mix.
- Repeat with the other cake mix and pie.
- Bake as directed on the cake mix box.
- Let cool completely.
- Remove from pans.
- Stack one layer on a cake stand.
- Top with a layer of frosting then add the second layer of pie baked into cake.
- Frost as usual.
- If adding, top with extra cherry pie filling.
Notes
- Personally, I wouldn’t go above 3 layers of pie cake. It seems like it wouldn’t be very stable.
- I used frozen pies so I made them the night before and let them sit overnight so they were at room temperature.
- An electric carver would cut this pie cake perfectly. But this cake saw is our favorite cutter and it worked pretty well too.
- You can substitute whatever flavors you want in this dessert! Chocolate cake would be delish with cherry pie filling!
sandra garza says
I’m going to try this this year but I’m going to make singles…a apple pie in a yellow cake and a pumlkin pie in a carrot cake I think that will work better for my pickie people. I will do cool whip icing as no one likes any other icings and I think it should be easier to cut…thanks for the recipe…sandi
Sharon Garofalow says
That’s a great idea to do them as single cakes! Let me know how they turn out!
Beth says
Making a spice cake with an apple crumb pie baked in & cinnamon cream cheese frosting for a surprise NYE dessert tonight!
Vanessa says
OMG! This is brilliant beyond belief! Note to self to remember this marvelous invention when the next Birthday rolls around.
Sharon Garofalow says
It’s so much fun! Everyone loves it and it is way easier than it seems!!!