Home » Cocktails » Best Rum Punch Recipe for a Party

Best Rum Punch Recipe for a Party


This is the best rum punch recipe. It’s made with grapefruit rum and SO tasty! It’s perfect to serve a crowd for a party and feels like a tropical vacation in a glass!

Delicious rum punch recipe with fresh citrus and vanilla bean and cinnamon simple syrup in a punch bowl surrounded by punch glasses.
Let’s make the best rum punch for summer gatherings!

I was invited to participate in the Captain Morgan Memorial Day Punch Recipe Competition. I was sent a bottle of their delicious Grapefruit Rum and a stipend to purchase the other ingredients I needed. Then I was set loose to create a signature punch recipe that I would want to share with my friends.

The Best Rum Punch for Entertaining

THIS! This is the best spiced rum punch recipe. EVER. It is sweet with some spice (not like hot spice, like exotic spice), it has citrus but I wouldn’t classify this a fruit punch. It is just plain delicious.

Related Post: Champagne Punch

The first sip of this party punch with rum pretty much stops you in your tracks. Warning bells go off in your head because you know you’re in trouble. You taste a bit of the alcohol, but this is that cocktail that you can drink all evening.

And then all of a sudden, there’s a lampshade on your head!


Ingredients to make the best ever rum punch recipe.
Here’s what you’ll need to make this tiki rum punch.

I chose to use the Grapefruit Rum because although it has a citrus flavor, I knew it wouldn’t play too sweet or tropical.

And I can’t quit the Captain Morgan 1671 spiced rum (it is a limited edition and not on their site anymore but my BevMo had it – but you could probably also swap it for the Black Spiced Rum for the same effect).

I wanted the spice notes to be warm and exotic to play up the spiced rum so I decided on making a vanilla bean and cinnamon simple syrup. I brightened it all up with fresh lime and orange juice and topped it with a little bit of Bittermans Tiki bitters.

I’m OBSESSED with flavored bitters now. I will now be taking payments in the form of Bittermans bitters.

And water. A punch is 25% water typically. I bet you didn’t know that. This contest has left me full of punch trivia. (note: You will need to make the simple syrup ahead of time.

But if you don’t have the time to wait for the flavors to really infuse, 5 hours to overnight, you should make it, let it cool and use it. It will still have tons of delicious flavor.But for optimal flavor give yourself plenty of time to steep the spices).

How to Make Tiki Rum Punch

Woman measuring rum with a jigger and adding it to a pitcher.

Step 1

To your pitcher, add simple syrup, grapefruit rum, spiced rum, lime juice, orange juice, and water.

Woman adding bitters to a rum punch recipe for a party.

Step 2

I finished up with about 6 drops of bitters.

Woman pouring punch into a punch bowl with a large block of ice.

Step 3

Mix well.

Then add the punch to a punch bowl.

Rum punch in a punch bowl and topped with edible flowers next to cups and a ladel.

Step 4

I then topped it with some edible flowers because they are so pretty. Serving punch doesn’t have to be formal.

You don’t need a crystal punch bowl to dazzle your friends. You can use anything. Be creative! The point of punch is to share it with your friends.

Woman ladeling tiki rum punch into a glass.

This made about 6 servings. But this is one of those drinks you just can’t get enough of. You can totally make this ahead of time and refill as needed.

And next time I make this I am going to double the recipe.

Serve it up and enjoy each other’s company.

Rum punch recipe with grapefruit rum and a vanilla bean and cinnamon simple syrup in a punch bowl surrounded by glasses of punch.

Creating this punch literally kept me up at night. I share cocktail recipes on here all the time but I’ve always kept them really easy because that is my jam. But for this punch I had a definite flavor profile in mind and had to figure out how to get there.

I did tons of research, I did a lot of testing (burp) and I am super happy with how this came out! I adore the punch at Workshop Kitchen in Palm Springs and wanted there to be some spice notes like they have.

As I read more about punches, I learned that historically, punches always had spice. So I knew I was on the right track.

Do you have a go-to easy rum punch recipe? Now you do.

Close up image of rum punch in a small glass and topped with flowers.


Making an easy ice block for punch.

Punch is usually served over a large ice block. Because I went with an untraditional size for my punch bowl, I had to create a custom ice block. I found a shape that I liked in the form, this Zico container, and used it to make an ice block.

Because the bottom was a little bit wider than the top, I just cut the container off when I was ready to use it.

Woman holding a glass of rum punch topped with a flower.

Our Experience with Captain Morgan

This was such a fun project to be part of! I am super proud of this rum party punch recipe and can’t wait to make it again. My fingers are crossed that I win and get to go hear some rad bands at a fun music festival.

You can follow along with all the summer awesomeness that Captain Morgan has to offer by searching for #SunsOutRumsOut on social media. And Chrissy Teigen as Paquita Pantalones?! So great! Watch the video!

And I have to give a little shout out to my friend Erika and Missy Misdemeanor Elliott for helping me name this! Naming drinks is hard!

And guess what, they are going to vote on recipes and if I win, I will get to go to the Firefly Music Festival. You know what a music lover I am so of course I wanted to participate.

And with the promotion hashtag #SunsOutBunsOut, how could I resist. It might be my favorite hashtag ever! So without further ado, I give you We Rum This Punch.

Thank you for supporting the awesome brands, like Captain Morgan, who let me be creative and share all the boozy awesomeness with you!

Save and pin this recipe for later!

Save this recipe for later by pinning it or clicking the teal heart at the bottom right of the page. For more recipes make sure you’re following me on Pinterest, Instagram and like my page on Facebook. If you make this recipe, be sure to leave a star rating and tag me in your pictures!

More Simple Punch Recipes

A glass of tiki rum punch on top of a brightly colored cloth.

Easy Rum Punch Recipe for Entertaining

This spiced rum punch is easy drinking with notes of vanilla and cinnamon and the perfect amount of citrus. Meant to be shared with friends!
5 from 3 votes
Print Pin Rate
Course: cocktails
Cuisine: American
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Total Time: 15 minutes
Calories: 124kcal
Servings: 8



  • To a pitcher, add the simple syrup, grapefruit rum, spiced rum, lime juice, orange juice, water and bitters.
  • You can find the simple syrup recipe here: https://www.cupcakesandcutlery.com/vanilla-bean-and-cinnamon-simple-syrup/
  • Mix well.
  • Pour over a large ice block in a punch bowl.
  • Top with edible flowers (optional, but it sure is pretty!)
  • Serve small-ish portions in punch cups or other short drinking glass.
  • Enjoy responsibly.
  • You are probably going to want to quadruple this recipe.


**Note: Nutrition facts may vary.


Serving: 1g | Calories: 124kcal | Carbohydrates: 13g | Protein: 0.2g | Fat: 0.03g | Saturated Fat: 0.004g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 0.01g | Monounsaturated Fat: 0.01g | Sodium: 11mg | Potassium: 40mg | Fiber: 1g | Sugar: 12g | Vitamin A: 29IU | Vitamin C: 9mg | Calcium: 11mg | Iron: 1mg
Tried this Recipe? Pin it for Later!Mention @CupcakesCutlery or tag #cupcakescutlery!

Click to share!


  1. Boyd Kobe says:

    I’m doing this punch for my Brothers wedding party..looks awesome.

  2. Um. You need to go to this music event and totally deserve to be there too! This drink sounds and looks perfect!

5 from 3 votes (3 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating